Это калькулятор по опубликованной методике, не индивидуальная инвестиционная рекомендация. This calculator applies a published method. It is not personal investment advice.

Value averaging and dollar-cost averaging

Both methods save toward one sum. Dollar-cost averaging — усреднение стоимости — decides the contribution in advance. Value averaging — усреднение ценности — decides what the account should be worth, and the trade is whatever gap is left.

A comparison of rules, not of results. The book studies history; this site does not promise that one method beats the other.
Dollar-cost averagingValue averaging
Fixed in advanceThe contribution, sometimes growing at gThe account value at each step
What the trade depends onThe calendar onlyThe gap between the target and the holding’s price
SalesThe rule itself does not sellAbove the line, it sells. You can skip that
Wiley sheetAPPCHAP4, pp. 83–85APPCHAP5, pp. 97–99

How Chapter 4 finds the contribution

Shares you already hold are the first pot. At the horizon the sheet values them as V × (1+r)^n, cell D10. Whatever is still missing from the goal is the second pot, D12. That pot is the growing series C, C(1+g), C(1+g)^2, and so on. Its future value is D13:

C × ((1+r)^n − (1+g)^n) / (r − g)

The file has no solved cell. The label tells you to nudge the inputs until E13 says “High Enough” (within 1% of the required second pot). The calculator uses the C that makes D13 equal D12, the closed form of that same search. If r = g the sheet would divide by zero; the limit of D13 is used instead.

The amount column in the converted file (G3 = C×(1+g), then repeated multiplication by (1+g)) is one growth step ahead of the series whose future value equals D13. The sample on the sheet (a contribution of 126.16 toward a goal of 100,000) was tuned to D13, not to column G. The plan here follows D13: month m contributes C×(1+g)^(m−1).

How Chapter 5 finds the path

Instead of a fixed contribution there is a curve of account value. R, T, t, and C come from the goal, today’s value, the number of months, and the two rates — the formulas are on the explainer and on the calculator, with the cell next to each figure. The planned contribution of a month is not the C in the formula. That C is the curve’s coefficient. The planned contribution is the cash that reaches the next point if the holding earned exactly r over the month:

Path(k) − Path(k−1) × (1+r)

If the market did not earn r, the trade is different. The gap stays in the side fund.

What this site does not do

It does not say “buy this fund”, and it does not score which method would have won on past prices. Chapter 7 of the book is about how wide returns can be, not about picking a security: one random price-index path sits on the calculator and on the book page. SPYM, VOO, VUAA, TMOS, SBMX, and EQMX are in the form only as examples, so there is a ticker to price.

Calculate both paths